"It's not about what they tell you, it's about what they don't."
~ Bob Fiddaman, Author, Blogger, Researcher, Recipient of two Human Rights awards
Researching drug company and regulatory malfeasance for over 16 years
Humanist, humorist
Tuesday, March 11, 2014
A Search for Justice – Death in Bray - Review
To write an opinion piece without offending is always going to be tricky. In the past I have wrote many articles where I have never really given any thought to my opinions hurting anyone because, in the main, I write about pharmaceutical companies, medicine regulators and psychiatrists whom I don't really care much for.
This piece is different as it concerns a number of people who are all suffering loss, all, who I mention, in the following piece, are searching for answers. We have a bunch of people divided by opinion which makes it increasingly difficult for any of the parties to accept facts.
My opinion, it will be argued, is one of bias - I cannot refute this but can offer my reasons for sitting on one side of the fence opposed to sitting on the other side or, indeed, sitting on the actual fence.
Last night TV3, an Irish network channel, aired a 90 minute special that covered the death of 22 year-old Sebastian Creane. The documentary, 'A Search for Justice – Death in Bray', has, if anything, raised some questions that need answering.
Before I go on I would just like to stipulate that I did not know Sebastian Creane nor Shane Clancy. I have, since this tragic incident, met with Shane Clancy's mother, partner and family on numerous occasions and they, like other families I have met and wrote about, have become good friends.
So, many may think that my bias will originate from this friendship. I can state clearly that this is not the case.
It was my father who, many years ago, said to me, "Always write about the things you know about", which is something that I have tried to do. As a writer my job is similar to the programme-makers of 'A Search for Justice – Death in Bray' in as much that I wish to raise certain concerns and my ultimate wish is that those concerns are debated.
Watching the documentary was difficult as many people have been affected by the tragedy it covered, none more so than the parents of Sebastian Creane and Shane Clancy.
Sebastian Creane, 22, was stabbed to death on August 16, 2009, by Shane Clancy, 22, who then killed himself at the Creane family home in Bray. A subsequent inquest into the alleged suicide of Clancy resulted in a coroner's decision, based on evidence given, of an "open verdict".
This, it seemed, was the basis of 'A Search for Justice – Death in Bray'.
Sebastian Creane parents, Nuala and Jay, were not happy with the outcome of the Shane Clancy inquest and both they and friends of Sebastian took umbrage to Leonie and her partner, Tony, appearing on The Late Late Show [RTE] some 6 weeks after the tragic incident.
If I were a neutral watching 'A Search for Justice – Death in Bray' I would have been of the opinion that Shane Clancy was a crazed young man who killed his former girlfriend's lover and then, after realisation of his actions, decided to take his own life rather than face the consequences of those actions. I believe the documentary, although compelling, didn't really delve into the evidence of antidepressant homicide/suicide.
I have been writing and researching about the side-effects of SSRi medications for almost nine years now and this case is not too dissimilar to other cases of bizarre beahviour from those who have ingested these powerful group of drugs.
Homicide Vs Suicide - What is the difference?
Homicide is the act of killing another.
Suicide is the act of killing oneself.
So, why did the coroner in Shane Clancy's inquest deliver an "open verdict"?
Well, based upon all evidences provided to the inquest it could not be deemed that Shane Clancy knew that he was killing himself [suicide]. The reasons why he never knew this have never been elaborated on [officially].
If Shane never knew he was about to kill himself then did he know that he was carrying out an act of homicide when he killed Sebastian?
This, of course, was never answered. Shane's inquest was not about finding fault or laying the finger of blame, it was, as all inquests are, about preventing any future deaths in the manner of how Shane Clancy died.
A very important issue was raised in the documentary. If Shane had not killed himself after killing Sebastian [and attacking others] then he would have been tried and [more than likely] convicted. I say more than likely because it is very rare for accused killers or criminals to be acquitted by using induced psychosis as a result of medication being taken. Rare but not unheard of.
In February 24, 2000 Connecticut Superior Court Judge J. Arnold acquitted Christopher DeAngelo of first-degree robbery on the grounds that the defendant lacked substantial capacity as a result of mental disease or defect. The judge specifically attributed Mr. DeAngelo's impaired state to his prescribed Xanax and Prozac.[1]
David Crespi plead guilty to brutally stabbing his five-year-old twin daughters to death, but there is one person that still believes he’s innocent: their mother.
Kimberly Crespi has fought for her husband from the beginning, forgiving him for his horrific crime in 2006 and now she wants to share their story with the world.
Mrs Crespi believes Crespi killed their girls because he was misdiagnosed with a personality disorder and put on a cocktail of drugs which in turn, caused a psychotic episode. [2]
Clinical psychologist, Dr. David Antonuccio, was one of multiple doctors who gave Charles Baymiller a mental evaluation. He said that she was displaying negative drug side effects prior to the killing such as agitation and sleep deprivation and had visited her doctor to address them. Instead, a nurse practitioner increased her dosages. He said that was not an appropriate adjustment. Antonuccio said that within weeks, the drugs could have caused her to be in a drug-induced state, where she would be in a “fog-like, sleepwalking” state and later have no memory of her actions. He said the known side effects of Paxil are irritability, aggessiveness and suicidal tendencies.” [3]
Probably the most infamous of all is the case of Donald Schell. Here's the verdict of the jury [Fig 1]
These are just four incidents, there are many more if one researches.
Irish psychiatrist, Patricia Casey, who appeared in the TV3 special, claimed that there is no evidence to suggest that the SSRi group of drugs can cause homicide. Some of the instances above, may be debated but, nonetheless, they show evidence that Casey claims does not exist.
Back in 2011 Lawyers representing Patricia Casey wrote to the mother of Shane Clancy. Casey took umbrage to a blog post and subsequent comments that appeared on the Leonie Fennell blog. Fennell was, in essence, told to remove the comments or face being sued by Casey. Back stories here and here.
Casey was interviewed and appeared in the 90 minute special last night, she made assertions that Shane Clancy had a "psychiatric illness" and did not believe his actions were due to citalopram he was taking. [Whilst alive Shane was seen by three professionals, none of whom diagnosed him with a psychiatric illness]
From what I can gather, Casey has based her diagnosis around reading documents from the case and reviewing CCTV footage of Shane Clancy on the night of the tragedy. She is, like many in this case, offering her own opinion. Casey, and her supporters, will argue that she is in a position to offer such evidence because she is a professional psychiatrist. End of the day Casey has offered an opinion that cannot be backed up with any scientific facts. She cannot prove, one way or the other, that her diagnosis of Shane Clancy is correct.
Casey also touched upon her links to the pharmaceutical company Lundbeck in last night's documentary. Lundbeck manufacture the antidepressant that Shane Clancy was prescribed.
Shane's mother, Leonie Fennell, had, back in 2011, highlighted a possible conflict of interest between Casey and Lundbeck [here]
Not only does Casey not believe that citalopram may have been the cause of Shane Clancy's out of character behaviour, she also believes that antidepressants do not cause suicide. [4] Something that, I believe, is an appalling and dangerous statement given the warnings placed on the packets of SSRi's such as citalopram.
The family and friends of Sebastian Creane and Shane Clancy will always have to deal with their loss, it will never go away. Both parties will also battle with the many unanswered questions. All parties concerned will try to seek justice. On one side of the fence we have those that refuse to believe the evidence that SSRi medications can cause homicide and suicide - on the other we have parents who refuse to believe that their son could commit such a heinous crime.
On a personal front, and to add some weight to my argument, I became suicidal when withdrawing from another SSRi, namely GSK's Seroxat. I also became aggressive and, totally out of character, went out one night seeking confrontation. The area I chose was a country park in Birmingham. I wanted violence and I didn't much care about the consequences of my actions if I would have had my thirst for violence quenched. [5] Luckily, there was nobody walking through the darkened country park during the early hours of that particular morning. Had they have been then I, myself, may have been the subject of much debate and maybe Casey, or any other psychiatrist for that matter, may have been convinced that I had a chemical imbalance in my brain that made me mentally ill.
In truth, I was prescribed Seroxat for "work-related stress"
Shane Clancy was prescribed citalopram because he was dealing with matters of the heart, a relationship split with his girlfriend.
I don't think for one minute that either of us were mentally ill.
Airing a documentary on such a subject was a brave move by TV3. It was very brave of Leonie Fennell, Nuala, Jay and Dylan Creane and Jennifer Hannigan to appear in front of TV camera's, by doing so they have people talking, writing, debating, insinuating. No statements, as far as I am aware were given to the programme-makers by H. Lundbeck A/S. I find this quite astonishing given that in one of their own citalopram studies 14 patients taking citalopram attempted suicide or reported suicidal ideation compared with 5 patients taking placebo,” [6]
As always, my thoughts are with both parties here. I cannot imagine what it must feel like to lose a child, particularly in such circumstances. I sincerely hope that one day the truth will out and that those left to pick up the pieces will one day be able to embrace that truth and find the minutest bit of comfort from it.
Bob Fiddaman.
[1] Court Finds Prozac and Xanax Cause Criminal Conduct
[2] Mother forgives husband for stabbing their twin daughters to death while driven crazy by Prozac and is fighting to have him freed from jail
[3] Judge gives woman probation in Incline Village husband's slaying after children request it
[4] "Antidepressants Do Not Cause Suicide" - Patricia Casey [VIDEO EVIDENCE]
[5] The Evidence, However, Is Clear, The Seroxat Scandal [Paperback]
[6] Forest Under Fire
Sunday, March 09, 2014
Is Patricia Casey the Chosen One?
Controversial Irish psychiatrist Patricia Casey
Irish psychiatrist, Patricia Casey, is at it again.
Once again she has come out and spoke about mental illness and antidepressant use. Casey, who has received much criticism from a number of bloggers over the years, is quoted in today's edition of The Irish Sunday Times.
Tomorrow evening TV3, an Irish television station, are airing a special documentary that looks deeper into the death of Sebastian Creane, 22, who was stabbed to death on August 16, 2009, by Shane Clancy, 22, who then killed himself at the Creane family home in Bray.
An inquest into the death of Shane Clancy revealed an open verdict, in other words the evidence given at the inquest was insufficient for the Coroner to return a verdict of suicide.
The TV3 documentary, 'A Search for Justice – Death in Bray', is set to cause much controversy with the families concerned and one has to ask why this case from 2009 is being regurgitated.
Patricia Casey, who asked to give evidence at Clancy's inquest but was refused by the coroner, is featured in the documentary along with members of the Clancy and Creane families.
The Irish Sunday Times today quoted Casey, it was a quote that made me choke on the toast I was eating at the time.
Casey claims that research literature "is not in any way convincing" that the drug [citalopram] can lead someone to kill. "I do not think it was the drugs", Casey told program makers, adding, "I believe it was a psychiatric illness he [Clancy] was suffering from."
Well, good to see that Casey is only offering her belief and no hard physical evidence to back up her claims.
This pretty much sums up Casey's chosen profession, psychiatry, a profession based purely on belief and...well, nothing much else really.
Casey never met either Creane or Clancy whilst they were alive yet, in this instance, she is offering her own diagnosis of 22 year-old Shane Clancy.
Does Casey have samples of Shane's blood or a frozen urine sample? Maybe Casey has a strand of hair and has ran a series of DNA tests that show Clancy had a "psychiatric illness"?
How can Casey, who has in the past claimed antidepressants do not cause suicide [Video below] diagnose a dead person?
Here's one way of looking at it.
Patricia Casey has been chosen by God to work his miracles. She can see what others can't see because God has given her this special power... in fact Casey doesn't even need to see those sickened by mental illness, she has a gift [given to her by God] that allows her to find diseases in dead people that previous professionals missed. Clancy was seen by three separate doctors prior to his death. None of them diagnosed him with a psychiatric illness...then again, they were not chosen by God to perform the miracles that Casey can.
Then again, even Satan can induce miracles [Check out the Book of Revelation for proof of this]
Today, and even in 2009, we have pharmaceutical companies who manufacture powerful SSRi type medications, openly admit that patients taking their drugs [particularly those up to the age of 25] have to be monitored as suicidal thoughts are known to be caused by the medication. Even drug regulators around the world have had to concede this one simple fact. Casey, however, does not acknowledge this.
Here's another way of looking at it.
Patricia Casey is wrong. Patricia Casey is burying her head in the sand. Patricia Casey likes the attention. Patricia Casey has a conflict of interest where the drug citalopram is concerned. [See here and here] Patricia Casey has a mental illness [Delusional disorder] whereby she cannot tell what is real from what is imagined.
So, has she been chosen by God to perform psychiatric assessments on dead kids or does she, herself, have some kind of mental disorder?
The TV3 special runs tomorrow evening. Sadly, due to contractual reasons, people outside of Ireland will not be able to see this. That shouldn't stop us from giving an opinion though. I mean, Casey can give opinions about dead kids she never once saw...so why can't we?
I have chosen my words carefully in this blog post. Casey, you see, has a habit of setting her lawyers on people who disagree with her. Case in point being the mother of Shane Clancy, Leonie Fennell.
Back in 2011 Casey took umbrage to a post that appeared on the Leonie Fennell blog. Casey's law team, Brophy Solicitor's from Dublin, sent Fennell a letter, the crux of which claiming that Casey had her reputation "destroyed or attacked" as a result of comments left on Fennell's blog [Letter here]
Fennell replied to Casey's solicitors who, in turn, wrote back to Fennell...
Dear Ms Fennell,
We refer to our letter to you dated 22nd June.
It is extremely disappointing that your reply to this letter consisted of you posting it on your blog along with the comment in bold “I will never be bullied, intimidated or silenced by Lundbeck or Professor Casey”.
We need to point out to you that when our client first came to us, we advised her that the comments you have now removed from your blog were seriously defamatory and that she would be quite entitled to issue legal proceedings against you. She did not wish to do so because she has enormous sympathy for the tragedy you have suffered.
You have removed the defamatory comments from your blog but you now accuse our client of bullying you and trying to silence you. This is despite the fact that we specifically stated that our client did not want you to remove your blog but only wanted you to remove the defamatory comments you made about her. What part of this constitutes bullying? What part of this constitutes an attempt to silence you? Are you saying that the simple fact that you received a solicitor’s letter asking you to remove certain defamatory comments which you subsequently removed, constitutes intimidation?
We must now insist that you remove this sentence from your blog as it is absolutely clear that our client is not trying to bully you or intimidate you or silence you. What she is trying to do is to protect her good name and she will not allow herself to be defamed again. We hope you will accept that the allegation that our client is a bully and that she is intimidating you and trying to silence you is both wrong and extremely damaging for her.
We have strongly advised our client that she should issue proceedings to prevent this repetitive defamation but once again our client has said that she does not wish to do so given the background to this case but she absolutely insists that you remove the defamatory comments that are appearing on the website at the moment and confirm that you will not repeat any defamation in the future.
Yours faithfully,
BROPHY SOLICITORS
As an outsider looking in it looks to me like Casey will never accept that antidepressants can cause suicide, it also seems apparent, to me at least, that Casey's beliefs about Shane Clancy's state of mind on that fateful night back in 2009 had nothing to do with the medication he was taking, despite overwhelming evidence from drug-makers and drug regulators that oppose her belief.
So, I'm throwing out three questions for Casey and for readers of this blog.
1. Has Patricia Casey been chosen by God to perform miracles through him?
2. Can Patrica Casey prove that Shane Clancy had a psychiatric illness?
3. Does Patricia Casey have some sort of delusional disorder?
TV3’s “A Search for Justice – Death in Bray” will feature interviews with Jennifer Hannigan, Seb’s parents Nuala and Jay Creane, Seb’s brother Dylan and his girlfriend Laura Mackey as well as Shane Clancy’s mother Leonie Fennell.
Judging by the media reports and TV critics it looks as though the documentary may portray Shane Clancy as nothing but a murderer. This saddens me a great deal because research and personal experience [6 years on Seroxat] has shown me that these drugs can turn even the most gentle, placid of people into monsters.
My condolences are offered to all of those concerned in this tragic series of events.
Bob Fiddaman.
Before Pediatric Psychiatrists Became Involved...
Scenario: Ashley is worried about her up and coming school exams.
1977 - Ashley's school offer her extra curricular activities after school and a one-to-one with her tutor to help with her homework.
2013 - Ashley is refferred to a pediatric psychiatrist by her school counsellor. Ashley is prescribed Zoloft to help with her exam jitters. Ashley kills herself by overdose in 2014.
Scenario: Bruce is having difficulty understanding his teachers in the classroom, this makes Bruce irritable.
1977 - School officials meet with his parents and suggest they move Bruce to a special school for slow learners. They agree and Bruce, with the assistance of highly trained tutors, is able to catch up and is returned to his school two years later.
2013 - Bruce is sent to a pediatric psychiatrist who diagnoses him with autism. Bruce is prescribed Risperdal to treat his brain disease. Bruce, at the age of 14, develops breasts as a result of the side effects of Risperdal. Bruce is bullied at school and, in 2014 stabs himself through the heart with a kitchen knife.
Scenario: Johnny and Mark get into a fist fight after school.
1977 - Crowd gathers. Mark wins. Billy and Mark shake hands and end up being friends again.
2013 - Police are called, SWAT team arrives and arrest Billy and Mark. They are charged with assault, expelled from school and sent for an evaluation to be given by a pediatric psychiatrist. Billy and Mark are prescribed Abilify to treat their brain disease and put into foster care.
Scenario: Michael won't sit still in class, disrupts other students.
1977 - Michael is sent to the Headmaster's office and given the cane. He returns to class, sits still and does not disrupt class again.
2013 - Michael is given huge doses of Ritalin by his pediatric psychiatrist as he has been diagnosed with a brain disease [ADHD] His school gets extra provincial funding because Michael has a disability. In 2014 Michael hangs himself.
Scenario: Bob breaks a window in his neighbour's car and his Dad grounds him for a month.
1977 - Bob is more careful next time, he grows up normal, goes to college, and becomes a successful businessman.
2013 - Bob's dad is arrested for child abuse. Bob is removed to foster care and joins a gang. A pediatric psychiatrist tells Bob's sister that she must have been abused as a child as well, reluctantly she agrees. Her dad is sent to prison. The pediatric psychiatrist has an affair with Bob's mom.
Scenario: Johnny falls in the playground and scrapes his knee. His teacher, Ann, finds him crying, and gives him a hug to comfort him.
1977 - Johnny soon feels better and goes back to playing.
2013 - Ann is accused of being a sexual predator and loses her job. She faces three years in prison. Johnny is sent to a pediatric psychiatrist and told that he has a disease in his brain [PTSD]. Johnny is prescribed Paxil, diazepam and mirtazapine. In 2014 Johnny kills himself by jumping from a 15 story office block.
Real-life situation: Justina is diagnosed with a muscle-wasting disorder. She is treated with the relevant medication and is getting on with her life as best as she possibly can. She develops the flu and is sent to hospital for treatment.
1977 - Doctor's at the hospital tell Justina's parents that the flu will subside with plenty of rest and to make sure she does not dehydrate.
2013 - Justina is assessed by a psychologist and told that she does not have a muscle-wasting disorder, in fact, she has a disease of the brain. Justina is removed from her parents and put into a psychiatric unit. Her parents are told that they may be charged with child abuse. Justina is kept from her parents and her condition deteriorates over the next 12 months.
The above is best summed up in this short video from the CCHR...
Bob Fiddaman
Friday, March 07, 2014
Lou Pelltier Speaks Out [VIDEO]
A video circulating on the majority of social networks shows Justina's father, Lou, speaking out regarding the abhorrent treatment of his daughter.
The video, which has been made available as a download via dropbox, can be downloaded here.
I urge readers to tweet this to the Boston Children's Hospital corporate sponsors [fig1]
Fig 1
The whole Justina Pelltier saga has been highlighted by many activists, it's opened a few eyes to those who took it at face value that the field of psychiatry and mental health workers actually know what they are doing - truth is, the whole field of pediatric psychiatry is one that needs to be seriously looked at.
Justina Pelltier is one of many thousands of children across the world who has been diagnosed with a mental illness that just not exist. The irony of this story is that these apparent mental health specialists have completely ignored Justina's real illness and even suggested that her illness does not exist. On this basis they have diagnosed a 15 year-old girl with a mental disorder, a mental disorder created by idiotic imbeciles who have co-authored one of the biggest scams of modern day history...namely, the Diagnostic Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders [DSM], a manual designed to entrap children like Justina Pelltier.
In the video Lou speaks of his daughter Justina...
"She is my hero and she needs to be a hero for every child and family in this country."
Speaking of a proposed new law Lou added...
"This law will state, very clearly, if you have a medical diagnosis and some hospital, doctor, psychologist, wants to come along and says what you have is not medical, it's up here [Lou points to head] that doctor, that psychologist will then lose their licence and go to jail."
Lou goes into detail of what happened to his daughter and how she has been kept away from the family home for 13 long months.
The 33 minute video is below. Please disseminate as far and wide as you can.
Here's other children, babies and adults who never beat the system.
Bob Fiddaman
Back Stories
Boston Children’s Hospital - A Prison For Children
Justina Pelletier: A Pawn in a Psychiatric Game of Chess
Marriott Hotels and the Case of Justina Pelletier
Car Trouble (Justina Pelletier)
Justina's Parents Still Fighting
Justina's Parents Still Fighting
"There's no argument that she was doing better under their [parents] care than under the care of the government" - Rev Patrick Mahoney
The saga continues.
With all the public outrage surrounding the case of Justina Pelletier one would have thought that the moronic white-coated buffoons, who diagnosed her with somatoform disorder, would have swallowed their pride and admitted they were wrong... and then released Justina back to her parents. That would seem the most logical thing to do, right?
Well, the words 'logic' and 'psychiatry' just do not bode well together.
Take a good look at the picture above. On the left is a photo taken of Justina in December 2012. During this time she had been diagnosed with mitochondrial disease, a disease that she was being treated for.
The photo on the right was taken last month. This after Boston Children's Hospital had disagreed with her diagnosis of mitochondrial disease and claimed she had somatoform disorder, which they claim is a recognised mental illness.
The photo on the right was taken last month. This after Boston Children's Hospital had disagreed with her diagnosis of mitochondrial disease and claimed she had somatoform disorder, which they claim is a recognised mental illness.
It doesn't take Einstein to work out which treatment was working better for Justina.
Her parents have, for the past 13 months, had their hands tied, having a gag order placed upon them that, should they break, they could be heavily fined or sent to prison.
Thankfully, the gag order has now been lifted and Justina's father, Lou, has spoken publicly for the first time. [legally]
Marriott Hotels, who are one of the Boston Children's Hospital main principle sponsors, seemed to be coming out in support of Justina last week when they tweeted the following message to me [fig 1]
You see, it's all about image and Marriott are probably looking at protecting theirs rather than really looking into the abhorrent treatment of Justina Pelletier by the very same hospital they support... the very same hospital who, according to Justina's father, have staff that don't believe that mitochondrial disease exists. That's quite a slur on Stephen Marriott, don't you think?
Here's the special WGBH News report.
“I will not stop until this nonsense comes to an end,” Pelletier told WBZ-TV’s Ken MacLeod. “DCF takes control of somebody and you just fall into this deep rabbit hole and there’s no way out.”Lou also features in a special WGBH News report [video below] and speaks frankly about how Justina was treated successfully at Tufts Medical Center for her mitochondrial disease before Boston Children's Hospital became involved.
"A young neurologist comes along and says there's no such thing as mitochondrial disease and that was the beginning of the nightmare"
Marriott Hotels, who are one of the Boston Children's Hospital main principle sponsors, seemed to be coming out in support of Justina last week when they tweeted the following message to me [fig 1]
fig 1
Sadly, it would appear that Marriott have now chosen to remain quiet. This particular stance astounds me given that last year Stephen Marriott, whose father presided over the Marriott International business empire, died at age 54 through complications from mitochondrial disease, the very same disease Justina Pelletier had been diagnosed with. The very same disease that those involved within the mental health system are claiming Justina does not have and does not exist.
Marriott should really step up to the plate here. In essence, the very same hospital they financially support are saying that Stephen Marriott did not have mitochondrial disease because it simply does not exist.
Marriott should really step up to the plate here. In essence, the very same hospital they financially support are saying that Stephen Marriott did not have mitochondrial disease because it simply does not exist.
"A young neurologist comes along and says there's no such thing as mitochondrial disease and that was the beginning of the nightmare" - Lou Pelletier
Marriott have been busy, it seems. But not in the way that one would expect them to be.
They will, of course, be concerned about their image and association with Boston Children's Hospital. This is apparent in the image below. It was taken from the statistics of my blog and shows the Marriott Corporation using the search term "boston children's hospital + marriott + justina"
They will, of course, be concerned about their image and association with Boston Children's Hospital. This is apparent in the image below. It was taken from the statistics of my blog and shows the Marriott Corporation using the search term "boston children's hospital + marriott + justina"
You see, it's all about image and Marriott are probably looking at protecting theirs rather than really looking into the abhorrent treatment of Justina Pelletier by the very same hospital they support... the very same hospital who, according to Justina's father, have staff that don't believe that mitochondrial disease exists. That's quite a slur on Stephen Marriott, don't you think?
Here's the special WGBH News report.
Bob Fiddaman
If you choose to tweet this story then please accompany it with the hashtag #FreeJustina
Back Stories
Justina Pelletier: A Pawn in a Psychiatric Game of Chess
Marriott Hotels and the Case of Justina Pelletier
Car Trouble (Justina Pelletier)
Thursday, March 06, 2014
Stop State Kidnapping by South Dakota
Last week it emerged that Justina Pelletier had been taken [by force] from her parents and put into care. Back stories here, here and here.
Justina's case has hit the newswires globally, her case has even been reported in British newspapers.
Justina, is one of many...
Last night I was alerted to a video that shows that Justina's case is just the tip of the iceberg. The video, entitled, Hearts On The Ground, can be seen in its entirety below. Every parent should watch it regardless of the age of your children.
While watching the video bear this in mind...
Every year, the Department of Social Services of South Dakota removes about 750 Lakota children from their families. [1]
While Lakota children make up only 13% of the child population of South Dakota, nearly 60% of the children in foster care are Lakota. [2]
Hearts on the Ground focuses on Native American families being ripped apart by the Department of Social Services of South Dakota who have, for one reason or another, removed children from the family home. This despite laws in place designed to protect Native Americans. Laws that the Department of Social Services of South Dakota have blatantly ignored.
According to the Indian child welfare act (ICWA) passed by Congress in 1978, Native American children are legally required to be placed with relatives or tribal members. [3]
A Native American child cannot be placed in non-native foster care facilities unless there are no relatives, tribal members or members of other tribes willing to take the child. [4]
In other words, the actions of the Department of Social Services of South Dakota is in complete violation of the Indian Child Welfare Act...yet they are allowed to get away with it.
Not only are kids taken away from their Native American surroundings, many of them are put into foster care homes and psychiatric units where they are prescribed medication without their parents consent. [5]
The video highlights just how these families are being torn apart by these white-coated morons who claim they have a unique ability that sets them apart from your average human-being. These knuckleheads can see things going on inside a child's brain that no other person...or man-made machine for that matter, can see.
Here's just a snippet of the transcript...
ZANE: They were giving me these uh drugs like you know Prozac and two other ones I didn't know the names of, which scared me because I didn't even know what I was taking, and they just basically said, “Take this,” and if you didn't take it they would physically restrain me and throw me in my room and not let me out you know for an extended period of time, until I wanted to take the meditation.
Zane was only twelve years old when he was placed in the Canyon Hills Psychiatric Facility and forced to take psychiatric drugs.
ZANE: I don’t remember any doctor you know sitting down saying this is what you’re taking, or anything they just kind of conveniently come up to me and said this is the new court ordered medication you have to take because of such and such whatever, you know behavioral report or whatever and they’d be like this is what you’re taking now. I didn't see a doctor I didn't have consent, my mom didn't have consent. they basically just said you take this or you’re in trouble.
Now here's the video. If, after watching, you feel compelled enough to do something about this, then a petition, Free the Lakota Children, can be signed here. If you are outside the US then there's a petition to sign here.
Let's put a stop to this utter madness.
Bob Fiddaman
[1] Administration for Children and Families, Child Welfare Outcome Report 2008-2011, page 311
[2] Administration for Children and Families, Child Welfare Outcome Report 2008-2011, page 310
[3] The Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978
[4] United States Code Title 25 - Indians Chapter 21 - Indian Child Welfare
[5] Internal Document
Tuesday, March 04, 2014
GSK to Face Negligence Claims in Adult Paxil Suicide Trial
Hot off the press this one folks!
GSK have been told by a federal judge that they must face a negligence claim brought against them by Wendy Dolin, a widow of a lawyer who claims her husband killed himself after taking a generic version of Paxil.
GSK and Mylan Inc, which sells a generic version of Paxil, had previously asked U.S. District Judge James Zagel in the Northern District of Illinois to throw out the 2012 lawsuit.. Dolin's lawsuit claims that GSK failed to warn users who took a generic version about a potential increase in suicidal behavior.
Dolin is the widow of Stewart Dolin, a partner in Reed Smith's Chicago corporate law practice group who killed himself in 2010 after taking a generic form of Paxil.
The U.S. District Judge told Mylan that they would not have to face any trial but said Glaxo was responsible for the generic drug's design and warning label and would have to face negligence claims.
Wendy Dolin is in good hands as the case has been filed on her behalf by Baum, Hedlund, Aristei & Goldman, the US law firm who have successfully hauled GSK over the coals on a number of occasions.
Background.
In June 2010 Stewart Dolin visited his family doctor who wrote him a prescription for Paxil for "work-related anxiety and depression".
Dolin's prescription was dispensed but he received the generic form, manufactured by Mylan.
Six days after beginning his course of the generic Paxil, Dolin left his office shortly after having returned from lunch with a business associate. He walked to a nearby Chicago Transit Authority Blue Line station at Washington and Dearborn in downtown Chicago. As a northbound train approached the station, Mr. Dolin leaped in front of it to his death. Blood tests taken with Mr. Dolin’s autopsy were positive for paroxetine.
The complaint alleges that Dolin, "exhibited classic symptoms of akathisia immediately before his death. A nurse alleged to have been on the platform at the same time as Mr. Dolin noticed that Mr. Dolin was “very agitated, pacing back and forth and looking down the tracks.”"
Dolin's widow, Wendy, maintains that "GSK nevertheless had knowledge that paroxetine use carried a 6.7 times greater risk of suicidal behavior in adults compared to a placebo. Plaintiff asserts that GSK has been aware of paroxetine’s association with this increased risk for over 20 years. Plaintiff asserts that GSK concealed the risk, however, and promoted its version of paroxetine, Paxil, as safe and effective."
Wendy Dolin also asserted that "Mylan was aware, or should have been aware, of this undisclosed connection between paroxetine and suicidal behavior, and the misrepresentation of the data supporting it. Nonetheless, Mylan continued manufacturing and selling generic paroxetine without notifying the medical community of the risk associated with its product."
GSK have, for many years, claimed that Paxil does not cause suicide in adults taking the drug, in fact their labeling only warns of an increased risk of suicidal behavior in users 25 years old or younger. Even drug regulators in the US [FDA] and UK [MHRA] have sided with GSK on this issue.
In 2001 a federal jury in Cheyenne, Wyoming, ordered SmithKline Beecham (now GlaxoSmithKline) to pay $6.4 million to relatives of Donald Schell.
Schell, 60, had been taking Paxil for just 48 hours when he shot and killed his wife, his daughter, his granddaughter and himself.
GSK were then defended by King & Spalding. It's King & Spalding who are defending GSK again. I do love a good brawl. My money is on Baum, Hedlund, Aristei & Goldman.
Baum's press release can be read here, also available from this link is the full judgement from U.S. District Judge James Zagel.
Personally, I have a love/hate relationship with GSK's lawyers King & Spalding. I love to see them lose and hate to see them offer paltry amounts of money to victims of Paxil. I wrote about them and a story I've been sitting on here.
The Dolin v GSK case is a trial I'll be keeping a close eye on. Who knows, I just might make it out there and sit in the gallery with nothing but a pencil and notebook...oh, and some popcorn and a fruity based drink...it won't be Ribena though.
Bob Fiddaman
Labels:
Adults,
Baum Hedlund,
Donald Schell,
Glaxo,
GLAXOSMITHKLINE,
gsk,
Mylan,
Paroxetine,
Paxil,
Reed Smith's,
Stewart Dolin,
Suicide,
Wendy Dolin
Car Trouble (Justina Pelletier)
"Chug, chug, sputtle, sputtle"
'Damn, my car needs fixing', I thought, as my car of 15 years came to a halt on a quiet suburban street in Birmingham.
That was 13 months ago. The story that follows is quite bizarre and has, to be brutally honest, frustrated me.
I managed to take my car to a local garage, it was a slow journey, pressing down on the accelerator would cause the car to jump and chug.
Anyway... on arriving at the garage I was given some strange looks by the mechanics. I booked the car in for a full service and checked my bank balance... this was going to put a dent in my finances but it needed to be done.
Almost 24 hours later I received a phone call. "It's the fuel injection/pump, it's completely gone...you are looking at 600, maybe 700 with labour."
How long will it take?", I asked
"Well, we have to order the parts so it could take up to four days for those to get here. We do have a garage about three miles away that you could take your car to though"
Given the second option meant my car would be fixed and back on the road within 24 hours I decided to head back to the garage to take my car three miles down the road.
Later that day...
I arrived at the garage and told the head mechanic that it was a fuel injection/pump problem. I ordered a cab and headed back home.
3 hours later I received a phone call. Apparently I had a cam shaft problem.
"What about the fuel injection/pump problem?" I asked.
"We don't see any problem with the fuel injection/pump, we ran a series of tests using our new diagnostic tool, it's definitely a cam shaft problem"
"Diagnostic tests?"
"Yes, we basically ask 5 of our mechanics to look at your car...we don't actually open the bonnet or put your car in the air to look underneath, we just...well, we just look at it then discuss what the problem could be"
"So, you are just guessing that it's a cam shaft problem?" I asked.
"Well, it's more than guesswork....the diagnostic tool has been proven."
"So, you are telling me that without actually looking at the fuel injection/pump you have diagnosed that there isn't a fuel injection/pump problem...in fact the problem is a dodgy cam shaft... and you have not physically seen the dodgy cam shaft?"
"Yes, correct sir"
"Well, when will it be fixed?", I asked.
"We don't think you are capable of looking after your car and have decided to keep it here. Furthermore, we have obtained a court injunction that prohibits you from talking about our decision and diagnosis to anyone."
Sounds bizarre doesn't it.
You can imagine my reluctance to leave my car in the hands of mechanics who hadn't bothered to look at the engine and parts that made the engine tick over.
It turns out that the mechanics were all former psychiatrists.
Now read the related stories below.
Bob Fiddaman
Related Stories.
Boston Children’s Hospital - A Prison For Children
Justina Pelletier: A Pawn in a Psychiatric Game of Chess
Marriott Hotels and the Case of Justina Pelletier
Friday, February 28, 2014
Marriott Hotels and the Case of Justina Pelletier
One way to give stubbornness a swift kick to the nether regions is to talk money... or lack of it.
Yesterday I Tweeted an article I wrote about Justina Pelletier to the Boston Children's Hospital's corporate sponsors. One of those sponsors, namely Marriott Hotels, replied. The reply [below] has since been circulated around social networks and Marriott are receiving much acclaim for their stance.
Here's the tweet...
The article I tweeted to Marriott and the Boston Children's Hospital five other corporate sponsors was critical of the treatment of Justina and can be read here.
The response from Marriott should raise the red flag for the 5 remaining corporate sponsors who have failed to speak out regarding the treatment of 15 year-old Justina, namely; Aquafina, Roche Bros, TD Bank, Waste Management and Toyota.
Those that are up to speed on the whole Justina Pelletier case will know that there's debate between doctors about her diagnosis. On one hand we have a disease doctor at Tufts Medical Center who diagnosed Justina with mitochondrial disorder, a chronic, genetic disorder that occurs when the mitochondria of the cell fails to produce enough energy for cell or organ function. Then we have another opinion of another doctor/psychologist who claims Justina has somatoform disorder, an apparent mental disorder characterized by symptoms that suggest physical illness or injury.
Last year Stephen Marriott, whose father presided over the Marriott International business empire, died at age 54. The cause of death, according to his father, was complications from mitochondrial disease. The very same disease Justina Pelletier had been diagnosed with. The very same disease that those involved within the mental health system are claiming Justina does not have.
Stephen's father also added, that his son was "...properly diagnosed about 20 years ago and in recent years had taken an experimental drug that probably helped prolong his life."
There have been many media reports that have suggested that Justina's medication to treat her mitochondrial disease have been stopped.
One has to applaud Marriott Hotels for taking a stand here. Okay, they are only looking in to the issues surrounding the case but to publicly admit that they have notified the 'appropriate people within the organization' is a brave move and one that may just haunt the Boston Children's Hospital.
It will be very interesting to see how this one develops.
I will, of course, keep you posted.
Bob Fiddaman.
Back Stories:
Boston Children’s Hospital - A Prison For Children
Justina Pelletier: A Pawn in a Psychiatric Game of Chess
Thursday, February 27, 2014
Justina Pelletier: A Pawn in a Psychiatric Game of Chess
Earlier this week I wrote about 15-year-old Justina Pelletier, a young girl caught in the mental health system and the opinions of apparent professionals.
In brief, Justina was diagnosed with mitochondrial disorder, a chronic, genetic disorder that occurs when the mitochondria of the cell fails to produce enough energy for cell or organ function.
Her parents, Lou and Linda Pelletier, took her for a routine visit to a Connecticut Children's Hospital back in 2013. Justina had come down with the flu, which can affect mitochondrial disease sufferers in a more pronounced way than the average person.
Instead of being treated for her flu, Justina was referred to a psychologist who, after a brief conversation, diagnosed her with somatoform disorder, an apparent mental disorder characterized by symptoms that suggest physical illness or injury.
24 hours later Justina's parents were served a 51A, a report of alleged physical or emotional abuse. By treating their daughter with medication for her mitochondrial disorder they were deemed to be 'abusing' her by over-medicalizing her.
This was back in 2013.
A few days ago, her parents attended a hearing at a Boston courthouse opposing the wishes of the Department of Children and Families who wanted to place their teenage daughter in foster care on Boston’s North Shore.
Bizarrely, Juvenile Court Judge Joseph Johnston agreed with the Department of Children and Families.
A gag order has been in place since 2013 that prohibits Justina's parents from speaking to the press about their daughter's plight.
Yesterday, the Boston Globe, who have been covering this story for a while, reported that Justina "is likely to remain for now at a Framingham residential facility where she’s been for the past month and not move to a Merrimac foster care placement that was discussed in juvenile court Monday."
This from the Boston Globe:
At the closed-door hearing this week, Juvenile Court Judge Joseph Johnston spoke about a plan by the state Department of Children and Families to transfer 15-year-old Justina Pelletier to Shared Living Collaborative in Merrimac. But this facility has apparently backed away from the idea, largely because of the highly contentious nature of the case and the national media attention it has drawn, these sources said.
Meanwhile, one of the sources said the judge on Monday expressed openness to allowing Justina to return to her West Hartford, Conn., home to live with her parents, as long as certain oversight conditions were met.Many social networks have been outraged by the treatment of Justina and various campaigns have been started, I myself suggested that Boston Children's Hospital's corporate sponsors be boycotted whilst others created Facebook pages and expressed their anger via Twitter.
It would appear that the "professional adults" just haven't got a clue what they are doing.
We have the medical opinion of a mitochondrial disease doctor at Tufts Medical Center who took into account all the evidence so diagnosed and prescribed drugs to treat Justina's mitochondrial disorder [part of his evidence was that Justina's sister also had the hereditary disorder].
Then we have the opinion of a psychologist who, after a brief conversation with Justina, decided she was 'faking it' - This opinion led to Justina being taken away from her parents and having her treatment for mitochondrial disorder stopped and being treated for an "illness" that she probably hasn't got.
After being passed around from pillar to post Justina still, after many months of uncertainty, still remains in limbo.
This is nothing more than Justina being used as a pawn in a game of psychiatric chess, and not a very good one at that.
It's time for Justina to go back to where she belongs - to her family home - to her loving parents.
It's also time for the mental health services involved in the decision making of this poor girl to take a long, hard look at themselves.
Chess just isn't for them. One has to have a certain level of skill to play the game.
Bob Fiddaman
If you are going to Tweet this story, please use #FreeJustina as a hash-tag.
Wednesday, February 26, 2014
Will Cameron Call off the GSK Hounds?
The South China Morning Post is reporting that Britain's Serious Fraud Office plans to prosecute or fine GlaxoSmithKline for engaging in bribery in China.
For those that don't know, GlaxoSmithKline were implicated in a series of bribery allegations last year in China. The Chinese government accused British pharmaceutical giant, Glaxo of paying almost $500 million in bribes, mainly to doctors who prescribed its products.
The allegations have been played down by Glaxo chief, Andrew Witty, who last year claimed, that there are control mechanisms in place to prevent bribery and other forms of corruption, but that the methods these individuals used “would have been difficult to find using our controls.”
The allegations also claim that Glaxo reps were trained to offer sexual services to Dr's in an effort to get them to prescribe more drugs. China’s official news wire, Xinhua, last year quoted a 35-year-old female “medical representative” who reportedly worked for a GSK regional sales manager named only as Mr Li.
The woman, named as Ms Wang, said “some executives gave clear directives to the sales department to offer bribes to doctors with money or opportunities to attend academic conferences.”
Ms Wang said she would even go so far as fulfilling some doctors’ “sexual desires” in order to “meet their needs” and persuade them to prescribe more drugs.
Furthermore, it's been alleged that Glaxo reps organised all expenses paid trips for Chinese doctors to tour the scenic river town of Guilin, China's most picturesque region which has long been one of the world's most famous travel destinations.
It's also alleged that Chinese healthcare professionals were also sent to other exotic destinations such as Hungary and Greece in an effort to get them to prescribe Botox, best known for its ability to combat crow's feet and other facial wrinkles. Botox has another 26 treatable indications which include chronic migraines, uncontrollable blinking and overactive bladders, ironically, losing control of your bladder is one of the side effects associated with Botox.
It will be interesting to see how this unfolds. Personally, I don't think the British government or fraud squad will intervene. Witty is a close friend of British PM, David Cameron and his leverage to pull GSK out of the UK should persuade Cameron to call off the hounds.
Bob Fiddaman
Monday, February 24, 2014
Boston Children’s Hospital - A Prison For Children
15-year-old Justina Pelletier was diagnosed with mitochondrial disorder, a chronic, genetic disorder that occurs when the mitochondria of the cell fails to produce enough energy for cell or organ function. From that point on she was being treated by physicians at Tufts Medical Center.
Her parents, Lou and Linda Pelletier, took her for a routine visit to a Connecticut Children's Hospital back in 2013. Justina had come down with the flu, which can affect mitochondrial disease sufferers in a more pronounced way than the average person.
Because of this, Justina was, on the 13th February 2013, transferred to the Boston Children’s Hospital.
Upon her arrival Justina, suffering from the flu and dealing with her mitochondrial disorder was sent to see a neurologist, who, Justina's father said, didn't look at her medical history or contact her other doctors. This neurologist, according to Justina’s father, said he thought the illness was all in Justina’s head — that it was somatoform disorder, a mental disorder characterized by symptoms that suggest physical illness or injury. In other words, Justina was faking it. Had this quack of a neurologist bothered to look at Justina's family history he would have learned that Justina's elder sister, Jessica [25], also has mitochondrial disorder. He would also have learned that mitochondrial disorder is hereditary. Justina was kept in hospital.
The following day, on the 14th of February, her parents went back to the Boston Children’s Hospital with a couple of advocates intending to have her discharged and returned to Tufts.
Too Late
By now, mental health services had dug in its heels and had decided that Justina could not be released. Her parents were faced with security guards and served a 51A, a report of alleged physical or emotional abuse.
To add insult to injury the Pelletiers were accused of over-medicalizing their daughter. Can anyone else see the irony in this?
Since when did mental health care about how many illnesses teenagers were diagnosed with or how many prescription drugs teenagers took? If anything, it's mental health services who dish out more harmful drugs to kids than your average drug pusher standing on a street corner, it's also mental health that label kids at the drop of a hat with fictitious mental disorders.
Justina was transferred to Boston Children’s Hospital’s Bader 5 psychiatric unit on April 9, 2013. There she was treated for somatoform disorder. According to a document from Boston Children’s given to the Pelletiers, Justina’s treatment included a “behavioral plan formulated with input from all relevant disciplines which will day schedule, feeding and functioning plans with a therapeutic approach.” Physical therapy was included as well.
Pretty safe to assume then that Justina would have been treated with some kind of "mental illness" drug. And these knuckleheads had the audacity to accuse Justina's parents of 'over-medicalizing'!
This is just utterly ridiculous. Exactly who is the ass in charge here? Which knucklehead oversees operations here? Has anyone within mental health got an actual brain in their head? Why on earth are they disputing Justina's diagnosis, furthermore, why have they held this 15 year-old girl prisoner for the last year?
Justina's parents are, today, holding a rally to create awareness about the abhorrent treatment of Justina and her incarceration at the hands of mental health buffoons who couldn't tell their own arse from their elbow.
Support is growing via the Protest for Justina Pelletier's Custody To Be Returned To Her Parents Facebook page and also via Twitter and other social networks.
Let's put things into perspective here.
Your child has a rare disorder. They develop the flu and you know that this could cause them problems. You take them to hospital because you are, obviously, concerned. Your child is then taken away from you, locked in a mental health unit and [we can only assume] drugged up to the eyeballs with drugs that can increase suicide, cause diabetes and that are highly addictive.
Let's hope these half-witted morons involved in the decision making are brought to task over their treatment of this young girl.
What an utter embarrassment.
Definition of hospital, by the way... an institution providing medical and surgical treatment and nursing care for sick or injured people.
...then mental health get involved.
Utter madness from these white-coated lunatics!
If you decide to retweet this story please use #FreeJustina as a hashtag.
Bob Fiddaman.
Related stories
Rally For Justina Pelletier This Morning At Boston Courthouse
Father So Heartbroken About Daughter Held at Hospital Against His Will He Just Defied a Judge’s Order to Talk to Us: ‘I Want to Have All My Guns Blazing’
UPDATE - Parents of Justina Pelletier upset after learning teenager will now be sent to DCF foster care
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Please contact me if you would like a guest post considered for publication on my blog.












